The Top 6 Thyroid Testing Mistakes Women Make (And What To Do Instead)
- Dr. Jessica
- 6 days ago
- 4 min read
If you’ve been told your thyroid looks normal but you still feel awful, you’re not imagining it
Here’s something women tell me all the time.
“I knew something was wrong, but I felt like no one was listening.”
You’re exhausted. Your weight won’t budge. Your brain feels slow. Your cycle is changing.
And somehow your doctor glances at one number on your lab report and says “Everything looks fine.”
This disconnect is one of the biggest reasons women stay unwell for years.
It’s not because you’re missing willpower or motivation.
It’s because your thyroid has never been fully evaluated.
After 17 years working with women who are tired of feeling dismissed, these are the six thyroid testing mistakes I see the most. And fixing them changes everything.
Mistake 1: Skipping Autoimmune Thyroid Testing
Why this matters
Hashimoto’s is the most common cause of hypothyroidism in women, yet many women have never been tested for Anti-TPO or Anti-TG antibodies.
Antibodies can be positive years before TSH rises.
This is why your labs can look “normal” even when your symptoms are loud.
A woman may show up with hair loss, exhaustion, cold hands and feet, and stubborn weight gain. But unless antibodies are checked, the root pattern stays invisible.
What to do instead
Ask for: Anti-TPO & Anti-TG
If either is elevated, it shifts the focus toward calming inflammation and supporting the immune system, not just chasing TSH.
Mistake 2: Thinking Medication Alone Will Fix Everything
Here’s the real story. Medication (like levothyroxine) supports T4 thyroid hormone levels, but it can’t correct the underlying issues that led you here.
If your:
iron is low
stress is high
blood sugar is unstable
gut is inflamed
sleep is poor
or conversion isn’t happening
…no dose of medication will make you feel like yourself again. This is why women say, “My dose keeps going up but my symptoms don’t change.”
What to do instead
Look beyond the prescription. Your thyroid can only work well when the rest of your body is supported. This means checking ferritin and iron to help with hormone production, making sure your vitamin D and B12 levels are strong enough for energy and immune balance, and looking at your cortisol rhythm since stress can block thyroid hormone conversion. Protein intake, blood sugar stability, gut health, and sleep quality all play a big role too. When these pieces improve, your body can actually use the thyroid hormones you’re giving it, and symptoms start to shift.
Mistake 3: Ignoring the Immune System
Most women are told nothing about this. If your antibodies are high, your immune system is attacking your thyroid. This isn’t a “thyroid problem.”
It’s an immune problem that shows up in your thyroid first. When you calm the immune system, your thyroid can stabilize.
Mistake 4: Only Testing TSH (and maybe Free T4)
Why this creates years of frustration... TSH is a brain signal. It doesn’t tell you what’s happening inside the gland itself or inside your cells.
It doesn’t show if your thyroid is making enough hormone.
It doesn’t show if you’re converting T4 into active T3.
It doesn’t show if stress is raising Reverse T3.
It doesn’t show if antibodies are quietly elevated.
Women are often told “Your TSH looks good,” but in the background other things can be off.
Ask for the full thyroid panel
TSH
Free T4
Free T3
Reverse T3
Anti-TPO
Anti-TG
This is the testing gives you the full picture.
Mistake 5: Treating the Thyroid in Isolation
Your thyroid never works alone. Your thyroid responds to your lifestyle more than you think.
When your:
stress hormones increase
blood sugar crashes
gut becomes inflamed
protein intake is low
iron stores drop
sleep quality dips
…your thyroid feels it.
This is why so many women say,
“I’m doing everything right, but I still don’t feel like myself.”
What to do instead, look at your whole physiology and consider these tests:
Adrenal stress – cortisol (tested in the morning)
Nutrients – ferritin, B12, vitamin D
Inflammation – hs-CRP, ESR
Metabolism – fasting insulin, glucose
Liver function – ALT
Each of these markers reveals a piece of the puzzle. When tested together, they explain what standard thyroid panels miss and show a clear path forward.
Mistake 6: Ignoring How Your Cycle and Hormones Influence Your Thyroid
The missing piece for most women. Your thyroid symptoms often shift with your cycle and no one talks about it.
You might feel:
more tired with your period
more anxious with PMS
more inflamed before your period
more overwhelmed in your late 30s and 40s
more depleted postpartum
That’s because estrogen and progesterone influence thyroid hormone conversion, inflammation, cortisol, blood sugar, and metabolic rate.
If we ignore your cycle, we miss half the story.
What to do instead, include hormone context in your thyroid assessment:
cycle regularity
PMS patterns
luteal phase symptoms
postpartum history
birth control history
perimenopause signs
mood changes, heavy bleeding
difficulty conceiving
Women don’t just need thyroid care. They need thyroid care that understands hormones.
The Bottom Line
If you’ve been told your thyroid looks normal but you don’t feel normal, it’s time for a deeper look.
Your symptoms are information.
A full thyroid panel helps uncover the pattern so you can finally move toward more energy, clearer thinking, better metabolism, calmer hormones, and feeling like yourself again.
Next Step
If this speaks to you, I offer calm, clear thyroid care for women who are done feeling dismissed.
Book a free 10-minute call to begin a conversation, one that centers your symptoms, your story, and your next step back to yourself.
Your complimentary discovery call is the first step in becoming a patient. If your body is asking for more than rushed answers, take that step now.
Comments